11 Comments
User's avatar
Sara Somers's avatar

I live in France. 8pm for you is 2am for me. Will these be recorded? In the future, some thought for your European fans!! 🤪

On Homelessness's avatar

I have not finished the first third of the book, but I was at your book launch last month and heard you speaking about it elsewhere. I'm really looking forward to reading this in community and also meeting you at Fountain House in a few days. To your discussion prompt, I am honestly troubled by the whole idea of narrative nonfiction; I doubt I will ever be able to sympathize or withhold judgment from Penny and his supporters. I have experienced homelessness, though I was never street homeless. I live with a psychotic disorder. And I am a homelessness activist. Even so, I would never presume to try to write from the perspective of someone living outside or underground because I have never been in that position. Just as it's treacherous for those of us with a roof over our heads to try to embody the perspective of someone who is homeless, it can be deeply problematic when non-disabled people choose to write about those of us with psychiatric disabilities. I have also been the victim of a hate crime on a crowded subway car by a person who seemed to be having a psychotic episode (nobody intervened). Even so, I would not try to put myself in my assailant's shoes. I'm open to having my mind changed but I had a visceral reaction to how you have framed this project. I think the Neely killing should be understood through the lens of the stigmatization and fear of people with psychotic disorders--like Neely--by people without psychiatric disabilities--like Penny. It seems to me that Neely's murder reveals power differentials that don't support an evenhanded "both sides" kind of analysis.

Stephanie Massie Clark's avatar

I appreciate you sharing about having a mental illness and having been homeless but never street homeless. I have been there, too, and I was afraid to share it.

Susan Miville's avatar

This is great! I am looking forward to the discussions.

Martha Bright Anandakrishnan's avatar

I listened to your interview on Conspirituality. Very keen to get into the book. Such interesting insights.

Stephanie Massie Clark's avatar

I don't know how to find the thread in which you asked the question regarding how we might feel about the technique you are using of "free indirect discourse," where you absorb your characters' ways of thinking and habits of speech in your own third person narration. The first couple chapters were tough for me, and it felt like too many characters were being introduced. But I hung in there because I knew you would deliver. It got sorted out in my mind and I really appreciate it, for the depth it adds. You do not allow any character's humanity to be avoided. And yes, it can be jarring to visit one consciousness and then dive into another, but the jarringness (is that a word?) actually is about not being able to squirm out of the awareness of that character's worldview as seen in the moment, and the contrast of another such view. Johnny is such a compelling character. I keep trying to imagine what kind of interviewing, or shadowing of this person was happening. I am just about a third of the way through. Looking forward to the book talks. I am going to email you a question about what I might share. I understand if you don't have time to answer.

Babs's avatar

I finished the book about two weeks ago. Obviously left thinking about so many issues. I would say most of all, to be more human, and to recognize in a real and significant way, the humanity in each and every one of us. To reach for understanding .

I have thought often, and been bothered most of my life, by the plight of the unhoused. ( Grew up in NY).

While reading from the comfort of my home, I feel and felt strong-- I would be different. I would be the caring one. The narrative makes me want to be a better human.

Yet, I'm walking on the streets and I'm the same. I can't seem to find the strength or the courage to acknowledge the human being, the person, bundled under blankets by his/her shopping cart of belongings. Why can't I say hi? Look them in the eye? Why do I continue to walk past as if they're invisible?

chiquita's avatar

signed up for the first one and really looking forward to this.

A question I've had after listening to a few of your podcasts discussing the book: you have emphasized the role of cities in taking care of and giving a home to people who are rejected in other places. In these discussions, you seem to really call out rural people for their small mindedness. This seems contrary to your message of getting away from tribal thinking and stereotypical characterizations of each other. Also, in my reading of the book I didn't feel like the city was taking care of Jordan, but that it was failing in so many ways. (despite the best efforts of some really caring people)

Patty's avatar

I have the audiobook. Is there a way to see what chapters you’re covering for each session instead of page numbers?

Anand Giridharadas's avatar

Great point! That is chapters 1-19, 20-33, 34-45