Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sara Somers's avatar

I live in France. 8pm for you is 2am for me. Will these be recorded? In the future, some thought for your European fans!! 🤪

On Homelessness's avatar

I have not finished the first third of the book, but I was at your book launch last month and heard you speaking about it elsewhere. I'm really looking forward to reading this in community and also meeting you at Fountain House in a few days. To your discussion prompt, I am honestly troubled by the whole idea of narrative nonfiction; I doubt I will ever be able to sympathize or withhold judgment from Penny and his supporters. I have experienced homelessness, though I was never street homeless. I live with a psychotic disorder. And I am a homelessness activist. Even so, I would never presume to try to write from the perspective of someone living outside or underground because I have never been in that position. Just as it's treacherous for those of us with a roof over our heads to try to embody the perspective of someone who is homeless, it can be deeply problematic when non-disabled people choose to write about those of us with psychiatric disabilities. I have also been the victim of a hate crime on a crowded subway car by a person who seemed to be having a psychotic episode (nobody intervened). Even so, I would not try to put myself in my assailant's shoes. I'm open to having my mind changed but I had a visceral reaction to how you have framed this project. I think the Neely killing should be understood through the lens of the stigmatization and fear of people with psychotic disorders--like Neely--by people without psychiatric disabilities--like Penny. It seems to me that Neely's murder reveals power differentials that don't support an evenhanded "both sides" kind of analysis.

9 more comments...

Ready for more?