I understand and respect this analysis of joining around what we have in common, and abstract from the particularities that separate groups. Let me say I'm a Black woman. I think that strategy may be effective to some extent, but the history of what has gone down here and lives systemically will not go away in this. Unless more people understand the embedded harm based on institutionalized supremacy that informs everything, I think we will be half-stepping. So, I think if people are clear about this in employing this strategy, it has a shot, because as you've said this stuff is very complex.
I’ve listened to this conversation twice now. It’s one of the most powerful interviews or discussions I have ever heard. Thank you for sharing it with us all.
Two of my very favorite writers and thinkers laying it all out there... I loved this exchange, Anand, and thank you for letting us listen in. "None of us are entitled to live in a society without really terrible ideas..." I am not sure if I am getting the exact words, but you said something like this, and it struck me as one of my core beliefs about co-habiting with other humans, especially the ones who do not see the world as I do. I am going to borrow it. It is a foundational idea in the interests of making peace, living in peace. Thanks. Another one: "to reduce someone to his/her 'stance' on something is ..." I did not jot down the rest of the sentence, but I don't need to. Just that idea is another real piece of clarity that you have the ability to see, and it permeates all of your work, which I love. What you read about what people really have humanly in common at the end of your book is another way of illuminating that very challenging truth. I also loved the question: "So why do we want to become a multicultural society?" My answer to that is, at the core: I cannot look at another person without seeing that they are me and I am them. And if any of us is not safe, I am not safe. I really know this. In order to thrive, thriving must be my business with nobody left behind. It is overwhelming and impossible. Sometimes I hate it and want to turn it off. That is why we need everybody to help, to see.
Anand, I'm enjoying the book and the multiple interviews you've had about it. This "emotional substrate" is a very complex issue indeed. The more I consider it, the more questions it generates for me. My experience has been that, yes, there can very well be underlying emotions that drive all of us to certain opinions. As a health care provider who embraces motivational interviewing, I have engaged in this with others. But there are additional considerations.
At what point do we hold people accountable for ill-informed opinions that they should be able to think through? What does that look like? What is the accountability for those who exploit the emotions of others for their own benefit? How do we deal with the fact that there are people who are incapable or jaded beyond the ability to be empathetic or consider the common good?
What this era has exposed is that there is an entire international cabal of self-serving amoral people, the Epstein class you discuss, as well as others who would like to be part of that cabal but do not have the money to "play in that club." How do we deal with the segment of the population that truly are filth. And that is not a cruel statement. It is a fact.
I worry that, should the Dems take the House and the Senate, they are going to fall into their usual "kumbayah" trap and the cycle will simply renew itself yet again.
As a retired geriatric/hospice social worker I couldn't agree more. EMOTIONS rule more than we realize when it comes to all aspects of our lives. Unless you have some form of mental health deficit that causes a lack of emotional intelligence. I have witnessed how "emotions" rule our lives, thoughts, and behaviors. Emotions Attach us to the most important aspects of our lives whether it is dying in his own home or the instant you hear the voice of your son who is in prison:
A young man was actively dying and family had been told there was a high probability he would not make it home - This young man had barely gotten into the back door of his home when let go! He knew he was home because all the signs of home exploded inside him once he crossed that threshold. A sensorial explosion of sorts occurs when we enter any space. The emotional and sensorial messages can be so strong and powerful that this young man released himself and simply let go.
Emotions are in politics because they are in all aspects of life that we value.
Emotional power is so strong, a mother had become necrotic inside, but still not letting go. She was holding on, waiting for something/someone, and the smell was overwhelming an entire floor in the hospital. The doctor told me, "Your the social worker, go in there and find out why she is still alive. Her body is trying to die but something is stopping her!"
I went into the hospital room, closed the door and looked at each of the 5 adult children with their spouses standing around the patient's bed. I explained what the smell and necrosis is. I told them their mother's body was dying inside but somehow she was still alive. I educated them about the abundantly clear fact. Their mother was waiting for someone or something before she would let herself go.
I observed as they all looked at each other, and clearly they knew exactly what it was. One of the adult children informed me that they had a brother in prison and they knew their mother was extremely hurt and disappointed in him so they thought she would only be hurt more if she heard from him.
I let them know that it was not their decision to make.
Their mother knew each of them were living successful lives. Meanwhile, she was left not knowing how her one son, the one who made a mistake that led to imprisonment, was doing. It took a few hours but once her son was on the telephone, I put the phone up to her ear and when she heard his voice, her entire body visibly relaxed down into the bed, the tension In her face resolved, and within minutes, she died.
Emotions include Love. I believe Love is the strongest power on Earth.
Brilliant conversation. Thank you! Yes, all politics is emotional. All relationship, all human interaction - business and politics and everywhere - is emotional. Yes violence is pain in public. Behind the pain is fear … terror often. Why do we not speak of feelings? The logic of the heart? The knowing? Because we’re afraid we won’t be taken “seriously”. And also we are not schooled in the language of feelings. “How are you feeling right now?” Would be an amazing question to sprinkle into our days. I’m so sad 🥹 so full of compassion for all of us looking for solutions out there. How are you feeling? Hugs, Christina🌺 PS: Perhaps in Book Group zooms, we’ll listen for the feelings that arise as we read Man in the Mirror.
I love the example of how to try to understand the underlying fears behind racism, transphobia, etc. I had never considered that the fears I have for my children about the climate crisis, AI, fascism, etc are similar to those of parents who worry about their children becoming transgender-we both fear a loss of control.
To what degree are people's concerns about immigration, also concerns about their children being able to compete for jobs and their economic well-being?
Of course, I don't know who said discomfort is not danger to you, but this book might be related to wha the person was saying to you: Sarah Schulman’s Conflict Is Not Abuse: Overstating Harm, Community Responsibility, and the Duty of Repair (2016)
Well of course, Anand. Values move not issues (values are feelings). Relationships (risking commitment) not transactions (quid pro quo) Relationships build; Transactions consume.. Courage to fight for what we value not only resist what we fear) . Love, Power & Justice (Tillich).. Power without love can never be just! Love without power can never achieve justice. Not compliance but agency (efficacy, hope, imagination). Resonance with not belonging to (Rosa)! Heart (why), head (how) & hands (act). Story (why) Strategy (how) Action (what). Not everything comes in threes (-:) but many things do!
Republicans wreck the economy, balloon the deficit & transfer wealth to the wealthiest.
BTW post covid inflation spike Biden had according to the Economist a US economy that is "the envy of the world." https://www.economist.com/special-report/2024-10-19
GOP/MAGA have a socialist agenda for the wealthiest.
#VoteBlue!
I understand and respect this analysis of joining around what we have in common, and abstract from the particularities that separate groups. Let me say I'm a Black woman. I think that strategy may be effective to some extent, but the history of what has gone down here and lives systemically will not go away in this. Unless more people understand the embedded harm based on institutionalized supremacy that informs everything, I think we will be half-stepping. So, I think if people are clear about this in employing this strategy, it has a shot, because as you've said this stuff is very complex.
This discussion should be required listening for all voters.
I’ve listened to this conversation twice now. It’s one of the most powerful interviews or discussions I have ever heard. Thank you for sharing it with us all.
Please vote
Two of my very favorite writers and thinkers laying it all out there... I loved this exchange, Anand, and thank you for letting us listen in. "None of us are entitled to live in a society without really terrible ideas..." I am not sure if I am getting the exact words, but you said something like this, and it struck me as one of my core beliefs about co-habiting with other humans, especially the ones who do not see the world as I do. I am going to borrow it. It is a foundational idea in the interests of making peace, living in peace. Thanks. Another one: "to reduce someone to his/her 'stance' on something is ..." I did not jot down the rest of the sentence, but I don't need to. Just that idea is another real piece of clarity that you have the ability to see, and it permeates all of your work, which I love. What you read about what people really have humanly in common at the end of your book is another way of illuminating that very challenging truth. I also loved the question: "So why do we want to become a multicultural society?" My answer to that is, at the core: I cannot look at another person without seeing that they are me and I am them. And if any of us is not safe, I am not safe. I really know this. In order to thrive, thriving must be my business with nobody left behind. It is overwhelming and impossible. Sometimes I hate it and want to turn it off. That is why we need everybody to help, to see.
Anand, I'm enjoying the book and the multiple interviews you've had about it. This "emotional substrate" is a very complex issue indeed. The more I consider it, the more questions it generates for me. My experience has been that, yes, there can very well be underlying emotions that drive all of us to certain opinions. As a health care provider who embraces motivational interviewing, I have engaged in this with others. But there are additional considerations.
At what point do we hold people accountable for ill-informed opinions that they should be able to think through? What does that look like? What is the accountability for those who exploit the emotions of others for their own benefit? How do we deal with the fact that there are people who are incapable or jaded beyond the ability to be empathetic or consider the common good?
What this era has exposed is that there is an entire international cabal of self-serving amoral people, the Epstein class you discuss, as well as others who would like to be part of that cabal but do not have the money to "play in that club." How do we deal with the segment of the population that truly are filth. And that is not a cruel statement. It is a fact.
I worry that, should the Dems take the House and the Senate, they are going to fall into their usual "kumbayah" trap and the cycle will simply renew itself yet again.
As a retired geriatric/hospice social worker I couldn't agree more. EMOTIONS rule more than we realize when it comes to all aspects of our lives. Unless you have some form of mental health deficit that causes a lack of emotional intelligence. I have witnessed how "emotions" rule our lives, thoughts, and behaviors. Emotions Attach us to the most important aspects of our lives whether it is dying in his own home or the instant you hear the voice of your son who is in prison:
A young man was actively dying and family had been told there was a high probability he would not make it home - This young man had barely gotten into the back door of his home when let go! He knew he was home because all the signs of home exploded inside him once he crossed that threshold. A sensorial explosion of sorts occurs when we enter any space. The emotional and sensorial messages can be so strong and powerful that this young man released himself and simply let go.
Emotions are in politics because they are in all aspects of life that we value.
Emotional power is so strong, a mother had become necrotic inside, but still not letting go. She was holding on, waiting for something/someone, and the smell was overwhelming an entire floor in the hospital. The doctor told me, "Your the social worker, go in there and find out why she is still alive. Her body is trying to die but something is stopping her!"
I went into the hospital room, closed the door and looked at each of the 5 adult children with their spouses standing around the patient's bed. I explained what the smell and necrosis is. I told them their mother's body was dying inside but somehow she was still alive. I educated them about the abundantly clear fact. Their mother was waiting for someone or something before she would let herself go.
I observed as they all looked at each other, and clearly they knew exactly what it was. One of the adult children informed me that they had a brother in prison and they knew their mother was extremely hurt and disappointed in him so they thought she would only be hurt more if she heard from him.
I let them know that it was not their decision to make.
Their mother knew each of them were living successful lives. Meanwhile, she was left not knowing how her one son, the one who made a mistake that led to imprisonment, was doing. It took a few hours but once her son was on the telephone, I put the phone up to her ear and when she heard his voice, her entire body visibly relaxed down into the bed, the tension In her face resolved, and within minutes, she died.
Emotions include Love. I believe Love is the strongest power on Earth.
Is the elephant in the room the climate crisis? Can you include this in your analysis? Isn’t the sense of abandonment really best focused on climate?
Brilliant conversation. Thank you! Yes, all politics is emotional. All relationship, all human interaction - business and politics and everywhere - is emotional. Yes violence is pain in public. Behind the pain is fear … terror often. Why do we not speak of feelings? The logic of the heart? The knowing? Because we’re afraid we won’t be taken “seriously”. And also we are not schooled in the language of feelings. “How are you feeling right now?” Would be an amazing question to sprinkle into our days. I’m so sad 🥹 so full of compassion for all of us looking for solutions out there. How are you feeling? Hugs, Christina🌺 PS: Perhaps in Book Group zooms, we’ll listen for the feelings that arise as we read Man in the Mirror.
I love the example of how to try to understand the underlying fears behind racism, transphobia, etc. I had never considered that the fears I have for my children about the climate crisis, AI, fascism, etc are similar to those of parents who worry about their children becoming transgender-we both fear a loss of control.
Fabulous conversation!
To what degree are people's concerns about immigration, also concerns about their children being able to compete for jobs and their economic well-being?
Of course, I don't know who said discomfort is not danger to you, but this book might be related to wha the person was saying to you: Sarah Schulman’s Conflict Is Not Abuse: Overstating Harm, Community Responsibility, and the Duty of Repair (2016)
Well of course, Anand. Values move not issues (values are feelings). Relationships (risking commitment) not transactions (quid pro quo) Relationships build; Transactions consume.. Courage to fight for what we value not only resist what we fear) . Love, Power & Justice (Tillich).. Power without love can never be just! Love without power can never achieve justice. Not compliance but agency (efficacy, hope, imagination). Resonance with not belonging to (Rosa)! Heart (why), head (how) & hands (act). Story (why) Strategy (how) Action (what). Not everything comes in threes (-:) but many things do!