NOTEBOOK: On the antiwar protests
Protests help societies evolve. And in the long run, the kids have a good record
A society is an orchestra. We all play our instruments.
Historically, students have played a vital role: forcing moral questions that sometimes blinkered, jaded, habituated, corrupted elders refuse to face.
Let them. Their social function isn't to be as faultless as your CPA. Their job isn't to be right about everything or to know how to run foreign policy or to have all the answers.
You do your job. Let other people do theirs. And everyone doesn't have to do their job the way you would do yours. There is a role for students to do what they're doing -- and there is a role for diplomats and everyone else: they can handle geopolitical maneuvering, legislating, explaining things in the news, brokering peace, mounting legal cases, writing human rights reports.
Enough with this strange allergy to hearing a tune played if it's not on your instrument, not played in your style. This is a society. It takes a lot of people going at it in different ways to get where we need to go.
Sure, students get things wrong. But they rarely have mortgages, salaries, speaking engagements, lobbying contracts, revolving-door jobs, board seats, advisory gigs, and all the other things that make some older folks unable — or unwilling — to see clearly what they otherwise would surely recognize.
And in the long run, the things students clamored for 10, 20, 50, 100 years ago are now largely things that even the most encrusted establishmentarians support and take for granted. So always approach student protests with humility. And curiosity. Take your own view. But be curious, not certain.
I will be the first to say: If the students really end up being proven wrong on this one, let's punish them the way we punished the people proven wrong on Iraq:
Magazine contracts, think-tank posts, and media gigs.
For more on the role of protest and the 2024 election, check out this interview with two voices from different sides of the fight.
And a request for those who haven’t yet joined us: The interviews and essays hat we share here take research and editing and much more. We work hard, and we are eager to bring on more writers, more voices. But we need your help to keep this going. Join us today to support the kind of independent media you want to exist.
And today we’re offering you a special discount of 20 percent if you become a paying subscriber. You will lock in this lower price forever if you join us now!